1. Home
  2. Money
  3. Banking & credit
  4. TD Aeroplan vs Cash Back
Comparison · Banking & credit

TD Aeroplan Visa Platinum vs TD Cash Back Visa for newcomers

TD’s New to Canada package lets you add one of two cards. The Cash Back Visa is free forever. The Aeroplan Visa Platinum is free for year one, then costs $89. Here is how they compare in real dollars. Figures as of October 10, 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Cash Back Visa: $0 fee, 1% on groceries, gas, transit and bills (first $5,000 per category a year), 0.5% on the rest
  • Aeroplan Visa Platinum: $89 fee (waived year one), 1 point per $1 on groceries, gas and Air Canada, 1 point per $1.50 on the rest
  • Welcome offers: up to $150 cash vs up to 20,000 Aeroplan points
  • Both: 21.99% purchases, 22.99% cash advances; limit up to $15,000 for newcomers
  • Aeroplan wins only if you redeem points for flights at good value

The two cards side by side

TD Cash Back VisaTD Aeroplan Visa Platinum
Annual fee$0$89 (first year rebated in the newcomer package)
Additional card$0 (up to 3)$35 (first year rebated for up to 3)
Higher earn rate1% on groceries, gas and EV charging, public transit, recurring bills, streaming1 point per $1 on gas, EV charging, groceries and Air Canada purchases
Cap on higher rateFirst $5,000 a year per category$80,000 a year
Other purchases0.5%1 point per $1.50
Newcomer welcome offerUp to $150 in Cash Back DollarsUp to 20,000 points
Purchase / cash advance rate21.99% / 22.99%21.99% / 22.99%
Travel insuranceNone included (optional add-on)Delayed and lost baggage, flight delay, rental car, common carrier accident
Mobile device insuranceNoUp to $1,000

Source: TD’s card pages and New to Canada package, checked October 10, 2026. Cash advance rate is 21.99% in Quebec.

How do the welcome offers work?

Cash Back Visa: $10 for a first purchase of $10, or $150 if you spend $1,500 or more in the first 3 months. TD credits it once, after 3 months.

Aeroplan Visa Platinum: 10,000 points after your first purchase, and 10,000 more after $1,500 of net purchases within 90 days. You must keep the account open and active for 90 days. Points can take up to 8 weeks to arrive.

For both, open the card by November 2, 2026 as part of the package. Either card also counts toward TD’s $150 bundle bonus. See the TD New to Canada review for the bundle rules.

Worked example: which earns more?

Say you spend $1,000 a month: $350 on groceries and gas and $650 on other things. You hit $1,500 in the first 3 months.

Cash Back VisaAeroplan Visa Platinum
Regular earn, one year$4,200 × 1% + $7,800 × 0.5% = $814,200 + (7,800 ÷ 1.5) = 9,400 points
Welcome offer$15020,000 points
Annual fee, year one$0$0 (rebated)
Year one$23129,400 points
Year two onward$819,400 points minus $89 fee

What are the points worth? TD values them at 2 cents each in its own estimate. At that rate, year one is about $588 and year two about $188 less the $89 fee, so about $99. But 2 cents is not guaranteed. Points have no cash value, and what you get depends on the flight you book. If you get 1 cent per point, year two is about $94 in points less $89, so about $5.

Which card fits which newcomer?

  • You plan to fly home on Air Canada or its partners: the Aeroplan card can be worth more, especially in year one with 20,000 points. Plan to redeem before you decide whether to pay the $89 in year two.
  • You want simple, steady value: the Cash Back Visa never charges a fee. You can keep it open for years, which helps your credit history.
  • You want travel insurance: only the Aeroplan card includes it. Health coverage for newcomers is a separate matter; check your province’s rules.
  • Your budget is tight: choose the card with no fee. A fee you forget to cancel costs more than most rewards.

FCAC’s advice applies here: rewards only help if they are worth more than the fee, and only if you pay your balance in full. At 21.99%, interest cancels any reward. Use FCAC’s free Credit Card Comparison Tool to check other cards too.

What to do before year two

  1. Put the card’s first anniversary in your calendar.
  2. If you hold TD Unlimited Chequing, TD lists the Aeroplan Visa Platinum as eligible for an annual fee rebate of up to $139. TD’s terms say it is for the first calendar year the card is open, so do not count on it in later years. Ask TD to confirm.
  3. If the points are not worth $89 to you, ask TD about switching to a no-fee card, and how a switch affects your account.
  4. Avoid closing your oldest card. See credit mistakes newcomers make.

Compare TD’s cards with other banks’ in credit cards for newcomers, or see RBC’s Cash Back Mastercard, which pays 2% on groceries.

Offer as of October 10, 2026. Card welcome offers in the TD New to Canada package: apply and be approved by November 2, 2026. Banks change offers often; confirm on the bank’s site.

How we handle offers. Offers on this page come from the bank’s own website and were last checked on October 10, 2026. Banks change offers often, so confirm the details on the bank’s site before you apply. No bank pays to be included or reviewed here. If a link on this page ever earns us a commission, we will label it next to the link.

Common questions

Which TD card is better for a newcomer?
It depends on how you spend. The Cash Back Visa has no fee and gives simple cash. The Aeroplan Visa Platinum gives more value in year one if you use the points for flights, but costs $89 a year after that.
Is the TD Aeroplan Visa Platinum free?
Only for the first year in the newcomer package. From year two the annual fee is $89, and each additional card is $35.
How much is an Aeroplan point worth?
TD estimates 2 cents per point. The real value depends on the flight and date you book. Points have no cash value.
Can I get both TD cards?
You can apply, but each approval is a separate credit check. One card is usually enough to start building credit.

Sources

Checked against these sources on October 10, 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.

General information, not financial advice. Prices, rates and offers change. Check the provider’s current terms before you sign up.