1. Home
  2. Settle
  3. Driving
  4. Public vs private insurance
Comparison · Driving

Public vs private car insurance: how provinces differ

Who sells your car insurance depends on the province. In some provinces a government insurer sells the basic policy. In others you buy from private companies. This page compares the systems and shows only the averages that regulators publish.

Key takeaways

  • Public basic insurance: British Columbia (ICBC), Manitoba (MPI) and Saskatchewan (SGI). Quebec’s SAAQ covers injuries only.
  • Private insurers: Ontario, Alberta, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island and Newfoundland and Labrador.
  • Minimum third-party liability is $200,000 in most provinces, $500,000 in Nova Scotia and Manitoba, and $50,000 for property damage in Quebec.
  • Regulator averages measure different coverage and years. Do not compare them as if they were the same thing.
  • To estimate your own premium, use the public insurer’s tools or get several quotes.

Which provinces have public car insurance?

Every province makes you buy car insurance. The big difference is who sells the basic policy. This table shows the rules as of November 18, 2026.

ProvinceBasic insurance sold byMinimum third-party liabilityInjury coverage
British ColumbiaICBC (public)$200,000 (ICBC Basic)Enhanced Care: no overall limit on care and recovery benefits
ManitobaMPI (public), Basic Autopac$500,000Personal Injury Protection Plan (PIPP)
SaskatchewanSGI Auto Fund (public), with your plates$200,000No Fault Coverage, or Tort Coverage if you file a declaration
QuebecSAAQ for injuries; private insurers for property damage$50,000 civil liability for property damageSAAQ public plan, no-fault, for Quebec residents anywhere in the world
OntarioPrivate insurers$200,000 (Insurance Act, s. 251)Statutory accident benefits; most became optional on July 1, 2026
AlbertaPrivate insurers$200,000 (Insurance Act, s. 571)Accident benefits; Care-First system starts January 1, 2027
Nova ScotiaPrivate insurers$500,000 (Insurance Act)Accident benefits under the Insurance Act
New BrunswickPrivate insurers$200,000 (Insurance Act, s. 243)Accident benefits under the Insurance Act
Prince Edward IslandPrivate insurers$200,000 (Insurance Act)Accident benefits under the Insurance Act
Newfoundland and LabradorPrivate insurers$200,000 (Automobile Insurance Act, s. 21)Accident benefits under provincial law

The minimum is only a legal floor. Public insurers sell higher limits. MPI, for example, says extra liability may be wise if you drive outside Manitoba, because court awards elsewhere can run into the millions.

How public insurance works in BC, Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Quebec

  • British Columbia: you buy ICBC Basic through an Autoplan broker when you insure a car. It covers $200,000 of claims against you. It pays up to $200,000 to fix your car when the other driver is at fault. In rare cases where you cannot get Enhanced Accident Benefits, Underinsured Motorist Protection covers claims of up to $1 million per insured person. Extra cover, such as collision, costs more.
  • Manitoba: Basic Autopac includes $500,000 third-party liability and PIPP injury coverage. MPI sells options to raise liability, such as $1 million, $2 million or $5 million.
  • Saskatchewan: plate insurance includes $200,000 liability. Everyone has No Fault Coverage unless they file a form to choose Tort Coverage. Tort Coverage lets you sue the driver at fault. SGI says both cost the same.
  • Quebec: the SAAQ pays for injuries from a road crash, no matter who caused it. You pay for it as part of your licence and plate fees. You must also buy at least $50,000 of cover from a private insurer for damage you cause to other people’s property.

How private insurance works in Ontario, Alberta and Atlantic Canada

In these provinces, private companies sell the whole policy. A provincial body checks their rates:

  • Ontario: the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA). From July 1, 2026, most accident benefits are optional; see Ontario’s optional accident benefits.
  • Alberta: the Automobile Insurance Rate Board (AIRB) regulates rates. Alberta moves to a Care-First system on January 1, 2027.
  • Atlantic Canada: a provincial board approves rates. In Nova Scotia it is the board named in the Insurance Act. New Brunswick has the New Brunswick Insurance Board. Prince Edward Island has the Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission. Newfoundland and Labrador has the Board of Commissioners of Public Utilities.

With private insurance, the same driver can get very different prices from different companies. So getting several quotes matters more here than in BC, Manitoba or Saskatchewan.

What regulators report people pay

About averages. We only show averages that a regulator or a public insurer publishes. We do not use broker, comparison-site or media figures. An average is not a quote: your own price depends on you, your car and where you live.

One regulator’s comparison across provinces (2024)

Alberta’s AIRB compares provinces in its 2026 Market and Trends Report. It uses earned premium for full coverage of private passenger vehicles in 2024. For private-insurance provinces it uses data from the General Insurance Statistical Agency (GISA). For BC, Saskatchewan and Manitoba it uses the public insurers’ rate filings, with some assumptions, and adds private optional coverage. For Quebec it includes the full licence and registration fee.

ProvinceAverage premium, 2024 (AIRB estimate)
Prince Edward Island$1,018
Quebec$1,159
Manitoba$1,186
New Brunswick$1,208
Nova Scotia$1,302
Newfoundland and Labrador$1,359
British Columbia$1,519
Saskatchewan$1,545
Alberta$1,706
Ontario$1,929

Source: AIRB, 2026 Annual Market and Trends Report, “How Do We Compare to Other Provinces (2024)”. Checked November 18, 2026.

Figures each province publishes about itself

ProvinceFigurePeriodWhat it measures
British Columbia$1,408Fiscal year April 1, 2025 to March 31, 2026 (actual)ICBC average premium, based on Autoplan premiums earned per Autoplan policy earned (2025/26 Annual Service Plan Report)
Alberta$1,9032025AIRB average written premium for full coverage, up 8.7% from $1,751 in 2024
Newfoundland and Labrador$1,3292023Average private passenger premium (Board of Commissioners of Public Utilities report to March 31, 2025)
Prince Edward Island$1,0182024Island Regulatory and Appeals Commission (IRAC): average annual premium for private passenger vehicles, from GISA data
OntarioPublished by FSRASee FSRAFSRA publishes its own Ontario average premium on its “Your average auto insurance premium” page (listed in the sources)
QuebecNot comparable–The SAAQ contribution covers injuries only and is set by the SAAQ
Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Nova Scotia, New BrunswickNot found–We did not find a current average on the public insurer’s or the province’s own regulator site as of November 18, 2026. See the AIRB comparison above.

Why the numbers do not match. The tables use different years, coverage and methods. For example, the AIRB figure for BC in 2024 ($1,519) adds private optional coverage, while ICBC’s $1,408 is its own average across Autoplan policies, which include Basic, storage and temporary permit policies. In the same way, Alberta’s $1,706 in the comparison is an earned premium, while the $1,751 for 2024 in the Alberta row is a written premium. Use these figures to see the general level. They do not predict your own price.

What is GISA? The General Insurance Statistical Agency collects premium and claims data from auto insurers. Alberta’s government appointed it as its statistical agent, and regulators such as the AIRB and the New Brunswick Insurance Board use its data when they review rates.

How to estimate your own premium

Regulators and public insurers list the same main things that set your price:

  • your driving experience and record (tickets and at-fault claims);
  • where you live (territory or postal code);
  • the vehicle: make, model, age and repair costs;
  • how you use it (pleasure, commuting, business or delivery) and how far you drive;
  • who else drives it;
  • the cover, limits and deductible you pick.

Then use the official tools where they exist:

  • Manitoba: MPI’s Insurance Rate Calculator and Driver Safety Rating Calculator on mpi.mb.ca.
  • British Columbia: ICBC’s estimate tool works for people who already have a B.C. licence and an Autoplan policy. For a new policy, ICBC says to contact an Autoplan broker.
  • Alberta: the AIRB site shows average premiums by postal code and lets you compare insurers’ rates.
  • Ontario, Quebec and Atlantic Canada: ask several insurers or a broker for quotes on the same car and coverage.

Worked example. To turn an annual figure into a monthly budget, divide by 12. Alberta’s 2025 full-coverage average of $1,903 is about $158.58 a month. ICBC’s 2025/26 average of $1,408 is about $117.33 a month. A newcomer’s quote can be much higher; see insurance with no Canadian history. Put your real quote into the car cost of ownership calculator.

Which system fits your situation?

  • Moving to BC, Manitoba or Saskatchewan: one public insurer sets the basic price. Shopping around matters mostly for extra cover. Bring proof of your driving years.
  • Moving to Ontario, Alberta or Atlantic Canada: prices vary between companies, so comparing several quotes before you buy a car shows you the range.
  • Moving to Quebec: your licence and registration include the SAAQ injury cover. You still need private insurance for property damage, and you can add collision and comprehensive cover.
  • Driving between provinces: check that your liability limit is enough where you travel. MPI warns that other places can award large claims.

For licence steps in your province, start at our driving in Canada hub.

Common questions

Which provinces have public car insurance?
British Columbia (ICBC), Manitoba (MPI) and Saskatchewan (SGI) sell basic car insurance through a public insurer. In Quebec, the SAAQ covers bodily injury and private insurers sell property damage coverage. Other provinces use private insurers.
What is the minimum car insurance in Canada?
It depends on the province. Third-party liability is at least $200,000 in most provinces and $500,000 in Nova Scotia and Manitoba. Quebec requires at least $50,000 of civil liability for property damage.
Which province has the cheapest car insurance?
In the AIRB’s 2024 comparison, Prince Edward Island had the lowest average ($1,018) and Ontario the highest ($1,929). These are averages for full coverage, not quotes, and your price depends on your record, car and location.
Can I choose a private insurer in BC?
Basic insurance in BC comes from ICBC. Optional coverage is bought through an Autoplan broker, who can tell you which companies offer it.
Why do different websites show different averages?
They often use different years, coverage types and data. This page shows only figures from regulators or public insurers, with the year and what each one measures.

Getting a licence in one of these provinces? See the licence guides for British Columbia, Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Quebec.

Sources

Checked against these sources on November 18, 2026. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.

General information, not financial advice. Prices, rates and offers change. Check the provider’s current terms before you sign up.